Pull up any listing that has been sitting for months with plenty of views and no sales. Nine times out of ten, the title is fine, the photos are fine, and the description is either three words long or three paragraphs of adjectives that never answer the question the buyer came with. The buyer clicked. The description lost them.
A title gets the click. A description closes the sale, or it does not. For secondhand and one-of-a-kind goods, where the buyer cannot compare your item to a thousand identical ones, the description is doing more work than it would for a new product, because it is the only place the buyer learns what makes this particular item worth buying.
This guide gives you a structure that works across categories, the details secondhand buyers actually need, and a fast way to turn an AI-drafted description into one that sounds like you and sells.
What a Buyer Is Really Asking
Every buyer reading a description is asking some version of five questions:
- What exactly is this? Make, model, type, era, material.
- What shape is it in? Specifically. Not "good."
- Will it fit, work, or match? Measurements, compatibility, color in real light.
- What do I get? Everything included, and anything notably missing.
- Can I trust this seller? Answered by how clearly and honestly you handled the first four.
A description that answers all five in order will outsell a longer one that answers none, every time. Everything below is in service of those five questions.
A Structure That Works for Almost Anything
I write every description in the same order. Buyers skim, and a predictable structure lets them find what they want fast.
1. The one-sentence identification
What it is, who made it, roughly when, in one sentence. "Pyrex Butterprint Cinderella mixing bowl, 2.5 quart, turquoise on white, made in the USA in the late 1950s to 1960s." If the buyer reads nothing else, they know what they are looking at.
2. Condition, in plain words
This is where most descriptions fail. Describe what you see and what you tested, in the order a buyer would care about it. For the bowl: "No chips or cracks. Light utensil marks inside the bowl, visible in photo 4. Pattern is bright with no fading or dishwasher dulling. Base stamp is clear." For a jacket: "Zipper works smoothly. Light wear at the cuffs, shown in photo 5. No stains, odors, or repairs. From a smoke-free home."
Name every flaw and point to the photo that shows it. A flaw the buyer can see is a known quantity; a flaw they discover on arrival is a return.
3. Measurements and specifics
Dimensions for anything that has to fit somewhere. Garment measurements laid flat, not just the tag size. Weight for anything heavy. Capacity, voltage, thread count, whatever the category needs. If you record these in your inventory system when the item comes in, they are already there when you write.
4. What is included
Lid, box, manual, cord, original tags. And what is not: "Does not include the lid." Buyers will assume the standard configuration unless you say otherwise.
5. Who it is for, briefly
One or two sentences about use or context. "A working piece for a vintage kitchen or a clean example for a Butterprint collection." This is the only part of the description that is allowed to sound like marketing, and it should be short.
6. Shipping and policy notes
How it will be packed, when it ships, your returns position. One or two lines. The returns post covers what to say.
The Details Secondhand Buyers Need
New-product descriptions can lean on the manufacturer's spec sheet. Yours cannot, because the condition of this one item is the whole story. A few details that make the difference:
- Brand and maker, stated and verified. If you know it, say it, and record it in the item's Brand field so it appears consistently in your listing, your storefront page, and anywhere your catalog gets syndicated. If you are not sure, say what you can see ("unsigned, in the style of") and do not guess. A wrong brand is a return and sometimes a policy violation.
- Marks and signatures. Transcribe them. Buyers search for them.
- Function tested, not assumed. "Tested and working" means you tested it. "Untested" is honest and prices accordingly.
- Smell, feel, and sound where relevant. Smoke, must, pet odors; the texture of a fabric; whether a mechanism clicks cleanly. Photos cannot carry these.
- Provenance when you have it. "From a single-owner estate in the Hudson Valley" adds interest and trust when it is true.
What to Leave Out
- Strings of adjectives. "Beautiful, stunning, rare, gorgeous" tell the buyer nothing and read as filler.
- Keyword stuffing. A paragraph of search terms at the bottom hurts readability and most marketplaces now penalize it.
- Repeating the title. The buyer just read it.
- Guesses dressed as facts. "Probably 1920s" is honest. "1920s" when you do not know is not.
- Anything you would not want quoted back to you in a return dispute.
Editing an AI Draft in Three Minutes
If you use AI-drafted descriptions, or a photo-first intake that drafts them for you, you are starting from a competent, slightly flat paragraph that describes what the photos show. That is a good start and a bad finish. Here is the edit I do on every draft:
- Check the identification. Is the item what the draft says it is? Is the brand right? Drafts read small labels unreliably; a brand name the draft pulled from a half-inch stamp needs your eyes on the actual stamp. Fix or remove.
- Add what only you know. Anything you tested, smelled, measured, or learned from the source. This is the part the draft cannot have, and it is the part buyers pay for.
- Reorder into the structure above. Drafts tend to lead with features and bury condition. Move condition up.
- Cut the adjectives. Drafts love "stunning." Delete every one and see if the sentence still means something. It usually means more.
- Point flaws to photos. "Light wear" becomes "light wear at the handle, photo 3."
- Read it in your own voice. Change two or three phrases to the way you would actually say them. That is enough to make it yours.
Three minutes, sometimes less. The draft saved you the ten minutes of staring at a blank box; the edit is what makes it sell.
Formatting for Skimmers
Short paragraphs. A line break between the condition section and the measurements. A bulleted list for what is included. Bold only for the condition summary and anything a buyer must not miss ("Does not include the base"). Most marketplace description fields strip or ignore fancy formatting anyway, so plain structure travels better than styling.
One Description, Every Channel
If you sell the same item on more than one marketplace, write the description once in your inventory record and let it flow to each listing. Edit the master, not the copies. It keeps your condition notes identical everywhere (which matters if a dispute ever compares them), and it is the only way to keep descriptions current when you have hundreds of items. The crosslisting post covers the mechanics.
The same master description is also what appears on your own storefront page and in your product data for search engines and, increasingly, for AI shopping assistants that read product pages on a buyer's behalf. The companion post covers what those assistants look for; the short version is that the clear, specific, honest description you wrote for a human buyer is exactly what they want too.
Before You Publish
Read the description once more and ask the five questions: what is it, what shape is it in, will it fit or work, what do I get, do I trust this person. If every one is answered, publish. If one is not, the buyer will ask it in a message, or they will not ask and buy from someone who answered it.
Then go find that listing with the views and no sales, and rewrite it.